Medical Verdicts

Was fetal distress diagnosed too late?


 

San Diego County (Calif)

With complaints of mild vaginal bleeding, a 29-year-old woman at 40 weeks’ gestation presented to a medical center, where she underwent 2 nonreactive nonstress tests and an ultrasound examination. The ultrasound examination demonstrated reassuring fetal status and the woman was sent home.

She returned to the medical center in active labor 11 days later, but reported decreased fetal movement.

Fetal monitoring demonstrated late decelerations with absent long-term variability and no accelerations. A scalp-stimulation test, however, indicated adequate fetal response.

Ninety minutes later, profound terminal bradycardia was detected on fetal monitoring, prompting the staff to initiate an emergency cesarean delivery. The child required resuscitation on delivery and demonstrated signs of a seizure disorder. She now suffers from mental retardation and profound physical disability requiring constant care.

In suing, the woman noted that she did not receive instructions on monitoring fetal movement when discharged from her first emergency room visit. Further, she claimed, the diagnosis of fetal distress should have been made earlier, and cesarean delivery initiated sooner.

  • The parties settled for $2.6 million.
The cases in this column are selected by the editors of OBG Management from Medical Malpractice Verdicts, Settlements & Experts, with permission of the editor, Lewis Laska, of Nashville, Tenn (www.verdictslaska.com). While there are instances when the available information is incomplete, these cases represent the types of clinical situations that typically result in litigation.

Recommended Reading

How to make note of a BRCA mutation
MDedge ObGyn
Abnormal quad screening: Which code is correct?
MDedge ObGyn
Misoprostol for prodromal labor
MDedge ObGyn
Tubal ligation at cesarean: No assistant needed?
MDedge ObGyn
14-day 5-FU application: Reimbursement unlikely
MDedge ObGyn
Obstetric ultrasound with no maternal evaluation
MDedge ObGyn
Replacing eroded sling mesh
MDedge ObGyn
Did delayed cesarean cause cerebral palsy in breech twin?
MDedge ObGyn
D&C, fetal death follow missed pregnancy
MDedge ObGyn
Trocar use blamed for bowel perforation
MDedge ObGyn