Commentary

Overzealous ART: Editor was “too kind”


 

Thanks to Dr. Barbieri for taking a stand on the “non-sense” that has become common practice for some practitioners of reproductive endocrinology: the implantation of multiple (more than 2) embryos. Though it can be truly rewarding and joyous to help an IVF patient conceive, these pregnancies contribute significantly to the incidence of premature births, neurodevelopmental disorders, chronic lung disease, deafness and blindness, infant mortality, and long-term behavioral abnormalities.

We must remember the admonition to “do no harm.” In my opinion, the creation of higher-order multiple gestations as a consequence of infertility care is inappropriate.

Dr. Barbieri, I couldn’t agree more with your editorial—though I do think you were actually too kind.

Jordan H. Perlow, MD
Phoenix, Ariz

Dr. Barbieri responds:

I thank Drs. Chen, Robinson, and Perlow for their thoughtful comments and deep commitment to trying to identify a constructive approach to the complex and common problem of multiple gestations resulting from fertility treatments. From my perspective, our field needs to try harder to mobilize experienced ObGyn clinicians such as them to help solve this problem.

Recommended Reading

Group Prenatal Care Said to Empower Women
MDedge ObGyn
Parvovirus B19 in Pregnancy, CNS Defects Linked : Although rare, central nervous system abnormalities manifest as a significant effect of this infection.
MDedge ObGyn
Investigational Prenatal Test Uses Endocervical Mucus
MDedge ObGyn
Small Study: ART May Be a Risk Factor for CHARGE, Goldenhar's
MDedge ObGyn
Teens' PMS Experience Mirrors That of Women : The worst symptoms among teens with PMS were identical to those reported in studies of women.
MDedge ObGyn
Women Over 55 Lack HPV Risk Markers
MDedge ObGyn
Safety Review of Combination OC In Adolescents Raises No New Concerns
MDedge ObGyn
Breast Ca Survivors May See Rise in Angiosarcoma
MDedge ObGyn
Breast Ca Risk Likely Higher in Prediabetes Phase
MDedge ObGyn
Vitamin D Deficiency Common in Osteoporosis
MDedge ObGyn