Medical Verdicts

Improper heart monitoring causes stillbirth


 

Undisclosed venue (Ohio)

A woman admitted to a hospital for delivery had spontaneous rupture of membranes. The mother was placed on a fetal monitor and given oxytocin. Fetal monitoring was reassuring for 48 hours. During that time the midwife, who had primary responsibility for the woman’s care, presented on only 1 occasion, even though hospital policy required examination every 24 hours, with more frequent exams after administration of oxytocin.

Two hours prior to delivery, the fetal monitor strip showed disturbing changes. The nurses were actually monitoring the maternal heart rate, not the fetal one. Once the fetal heart rate was located, a sinusoidal pattern was noted, but was not addressed for 40 minutes. Again, the nurses began to mistakenly monitor the maternal heart rate.

After the mother delivered a stillborn infant, pathology of the placenta revealed an abruption. The mother claimed the midwife was required by hospital policy to be present during labor. The defense contended that the child died from a viral syndrome.

  • An $875,000 settlement was reached.
The cases in this column are selected by the editors of OBG Management from Medical Malpractice Verdicts, Settlements & Experts, with permission of the editor, Lewis Laska, of Nashville, Tenn (www.verdictslaska.com). While there are instances when the available information is incomplete, these cases represent the types of clinical situations that typically result in litigation.

Recommended Reading

Excised lesions are coded by diameter
MDedge ObGyn
Code for hemorrhage depends on timing
MDedge ObGyn
Use -58 modifier only when D&C is planned
MDedge ObGyn
Monitor delay blamed for cerebral palsy
MDedge ObGyn
Is misoprostol wrong for induction?
MDedge ObGyn
What caused leak: UTI or PPROM?
MDedge ObGyn
Small-bowel transection causes death
MDedge ObGyn
Did OB ignore risk factors?
MDedge ObGyn
Woman delivers fetus’s head into toilet
MDedge ObGyn
Fetal injury from repeat vaginal delivery
MDedge ObGyn