|January 2011 · Vol. 23, No. 1
NOTABLE JUDGMENTS AND SETTLEMENTS
Septate uterus not corrected
until 2 brain-injured babies born
10 WEEKS AFTER A UTERINE ABNORMALITY was detected by ultrasonography, a woman conceived. The child was born with a congenital brain malformation that caused impaired articulation, comprehension, and speech. The woman gave birth 5 years later to a second child, who had congenital brain damage that caused hyperactivity. Following the second birth, the patient was given a diagnosis of a septate uterus, which was corrected surgically. She then gave birth to two healthy children.
PATIENT’S CLAIM The septate uterus caused congenital injuries to her first two children by limiting the blood and oxygen provided to the children during fetal development. An MRI should have been ordered as soon as the abnormality was found, or soon after the first child’s birth.
PHYSICIAN’S DEFENSE The uterine abnormality did not require further investigation. Many different things could have caused the children’s injuries.
VERDICT A $2.2 million New York settlement was reached: the first child received $1.45 million; the second, $500,000; and the mother, $250,000.
Estate of breast cancer victim appeals
COMPLAINING OF FATIGUE, a 44-year-old woman went to a university medical center staffed by residents supervised by faculty. Resident Dr. A discovered a 1.5-cm mobile mass in her right breast. Although he never saw the patient, Dr. B, the supervising physician, suggested a mammogram with ultrasonography. Results were reported as benign, and the patient was advised to follow up in 6 months, or earlier if her condition changed.
A month later, the patient returned to the clinic. Resident Dr. C advised her to have a biopsy; the patient declined.
She returned 8 months later, after the clinic sent a reminder. The skin on her breast had the consistency of an orange, and the lump had grown. A diagnosis of metastatic breast cancer was made. Aggressive treatment was recommended, but the patient opted for herbal and other homeopathic remedies.
PATIENT’S CLAIM The physicians were negligent for not diagnosing breast cancer in a timely manner. A needle biopsy should have been performed when the lump was first detected.
PHYSICIANS’ DEFENSE The treatment plan was reasonable. The patient declined the biopsy, and failed to return when her condition changed.
VERDICT A Tennessee defense verdict was returned.
ESTATE’S APPEAL After the patient died 2 years later, an appeal trial resulted in finding Dr. B 99% at fault and the deceased 1% at fault. The jury awarded $2.7 million to the estate.
ObGyn exonerated in Erb’s palsy case
2 WEEKS BEFORE GIVING BIRTH, a woman underwent a sonogram. A radiologist evaluated the images and did not report an abnormality. The infant was delivered vaginally by an ObGyn. Later, the child was given a diagnosis of Erb’s palsy.
PATIENT’S CLAIM The radiologist failed to properly estimate the fetus’ weight. The ObGyn used excessive lateral traction during delivery.
PHYSICIANS’ DEFENSE Both physicians denied negligence.
VERDICT The radiologist settled for $150,000 before trial. A Texas jury returned a defense verdict for the ObGyn.
Profuse bleeding; patient dies
AFTER BLEEDING PROFUSELY during laparoscopic-assisted vaginal hysterectomy, a 46-year-old woman died.
ESTATE’S CLAIM The gynecologist failed to recognize bleeding complications and transfuse blood quickly enough. Type O-negative blood should have been ordered because it would have been available sooner than type-specific blood.
PHYSICIAN’S DEFENSE Bleeding is a known complication of the procedure. There was insufficient time to effectively transfuse the patient.
VERDICT An Arizona defense verdict was returned.
These cases were selected by the editors of OBG Management from Medical Malpractice Verdicts, Settlements & Experts, with permission of the editor, Lewis Laska (www.verdictslaska.com). The information available to the editors about the cases presented here is sometimes incomplete. Moreover, the cases may or may not have merit. Nevertheless, these cases represent the types of clinical situations that typically result in litigation and are meant to illustrate nationwide variation in jury verdicts and awards.We want to hear from you! Tell us what you think.
OBG Management ©2011 Quadrant HealthCom Inc.